AI-generated editorial illustration for the article Why Four Products and Not Forty (no product shown).

Why Four Products and Not Forty

A supplement brand with 40 products is usually a brand with four formulas and 36 label designs. Ours has four, and that number is a decision rather than a starting point we haven't grown past yet.

What the four actually are

They cover circulation and everyday antioxidant intake through aged garlic extract with CoQ10 at 60 mg, organ sourced nutrients from grass fed liver, magnesium bound to taurine, and a zinc carnosine capsule with mastic, DGL licorice and glutamine. Each one has a single job. None is a twenty ingredient kitchen sink where you can't tell which component produced the change you noticed, and that's the part we're unwilling to give up.

They also share a manufacturing constraint. Each one has to survive its format, gummy or capsule, without excipients we can't explain in plain terms, and that rules out ingredients people regularly ask us for. Several work perfectly well in a tablet and turn to paste in a gummy. Declining a formula because the format can't carry it is slower than saying yes, and it's most of why our launch pace looks unhurried from the outside.

What a small catalogue buys you

The obvious thing it buys is attention. A formula we revisit twice a year gets more of it than one of thirty we glance at in passing. When we settled on a 90 count bottle at 2 gummies a day, which is 45 days per bottle, the argument ran for weeks. That count decides how often you reorder, how much packaging we ship, and whether a gummy is still soft in month three.

The less obvious thing is honesty about overlap. With four formulas we can tell you where nothing overlaps: none of them supply the same nutrient at a level worth counting, so you can take all four without totalling a shared ingredient first. Brands running forty SKUs usually can't answer that question at all, and their customers end up stacking three products built on the same base.

Aged Garlic Extract Gummies for Adults 25+, 90 Count

Small also means we answer the questions ourselves. When someone writes to ask whether the garlic gummies contain gelatin, the reply doesn't come from a supplier document three time zones away, because we wrote the specification. That sounds like a trivial advantage until you've spent a week trying to get a straight answer out of a brand that licenses its own name to whoever is cheapest this quarter.

Why we keep saying no

We get pitched constantly. A white label supplier can put a new SKU in front of us in about 6 weeks, with stock photography and a label we're permitted to rename. Most of those formulations are copies of whatever sold last quarter, at doses copied from the same source. We've declined far more than we've accepted, including some that would probably sell well.

Our test is dull. Can we say in one sentence why this formula exists, and does the ingredient have published human data behind it. A product failing either question doesn't ship, whatever the margin looks like. That's also why we reformulate rarely. Changing a formula each season is a way to manufacture novelty, and novelty isn't the same thing as improvement, though the two look identical on a product page.

What that means if you're deciding

If you want one bottle that claims to handle everything, we're the wrong brand, and there's no shortage of those. If you'd rather buy the specific thing and know what's in it, four is plenty. The aged garlic gummies are 90 count and 45 days at 2 a day, the zinc capsules are 120 capsules and 60 days, and both print every milligram on the panel rather than burying it in a complex.

Aged Garlic Extract Gummies for Adults 25+, 90 Count

Four also means nothing on the shelf competes with itself. Nobody here has to decide which of six near identical bottles gets pushed this month, and you never stand in front of a page wondering why two of them exist. That clarity is worth more to us than the extra listings would be, and it is the main reason the number hasn't moved.

We'll add products, slowly. The fifth has to clear the same two questions, and if it can't, we'd rather stay at four than ship something we can't explain in a sentence. A small catalogue is easier to defend, and it's also easier for you to audit, which is the real reason we keep it this way.

Frequently asked questions

Will you add more products?Show answerHide answer

Slowly, and only when a formula clears the same bar as the existing four.

Why is everything single ingredient?Show answerHide answer

So you can tell what a product is doing. Stacking four blends makes that impossible.

Can I take several of your products together?Show answerHide answer

Usually, but check the overlap. If two products supply the same nutrient, work out the daily total first.

These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.

Back to blog